JM&A Group: Strong Q3 F&I Performance Helps Offset Weaker Front-End Gross

Nov. 12, 2026 | |

Finance and insurance departments continued to play a critical role in dealership profitability during the third quarter of 2026, helping offset softer front-end vehicle margins, according to JM&A Group’s latest automotive trends report.

The company’s Q3 2026 Automotive Trends Report found that F&I revenue per vehicle retailed (PVR) and protection product penetration remained ahead of year-earlier levels, even as front-end PVR faced continued pressure.

The findings are based on data from more than 2,000 dealerships offering JM&A products. While the sample is not representative of the entire U.S. retail automotive market, it provides insight into performance trends across participating stores.

Protection Products Support F&I Results

Protection product sales were an important contributor to third-quarter F&I performance.

According to the report, product income represented 61.7% of F&I PVR, while finance reserve accounted for the remaining 38.3%. Product income’s share increased 0.3 percentage points compared with the third quarter of 2025.

Vehicle service contract penetration and products per deal also remained above year-earlier levels, although both experienced some month-to-month softness during August.

Guaranteed asset protection (GAP) penetration similarly remained ahead of the previous year despite modest declines during portions of the quarter.

The results suggest that consumer demand for protection products continues to support dealership profitability even as financing conditions become more challenging.

Affordability Continues to Shape Consumer Behavior

Higher borrowing costs, vehicle payments and negative equity remain significant influences on purchasing decisions.

The report cited average financing rates of 11.32% for used vehicles and 8.07% for new vehicles. Cash transactions increased slightly while financed purchases declined, reflecting continued pressure on affordability.

Average monthly payments were approximately $765 for new vehicles and $542 for used vehicles during the second quarter.

These conditions are affecting how dealerships structure transactions and present optional protection products to customers.

Implications for Dealer Agents

For dealer agents, the report reinforces the value of product training, consultative selling and consistent F&I processes.

With front-end margins under pressure, dealership partners may increasingly rely on F&I performance to maintain overall profitability. However, continued success will depend on presenting products in ways that address customers’ financial concerns and ownership needs.

Helping F&I managers explain the benefits of vehicle service contracts, GAP coverage and other eligible protection products may remain particularly important as dealerships navigate affordability challenges.

The findings also underscore the importance of monitoring both product penetration and income per vehicle rather than relying on a single performance measure.

Source: CBT News — JM&A Group reports robust Q3 F&I sales helped offset weaker vehicle profits, based on JM&A Group’s Q3 2026 Automotive Trends Report.